Biblion Bible Commentary
Read the introduction to 1 Thessalonians · About this commentary
Do Not Quench the Spirit
1 Thessalonians 5:19-22
19 Don’t quench the Spirit. · WEB
Two prohibitions against shutting things down, then two instructions that keep openness from becoming credulity.
Don't quench the Spirit. The verb is used of putting out a fire, so the image assumes something already burning that a person can extinguish. It is a warning about suppression rather than about excess.
Don't despise prophecies. The second prohibition is specific, and it explains the first — the likeliest way to quench the Spirit in that congregation was to treat prophetic speech as an embarrassment. Paul deals with the same instinct at length elsewhere 1 Corinthians 14:39.
But openness alone would be reckless, and the next verse balances it. Test all things — the word for assaying metal — and hold firmly what is good. The testing is commanded rather than permitted, and John gives the same instruction about spirits 1 John 4:1.
The order makes the paragraph work: do not shut it down, and do not swallow it whole. Verse 22 completes it — abstain from every form of evil, so what the testing rejects is dropped entirely rather than held at a distance.
settled What this mark means