Biblion Bible Commentary
Read the introduction to 2 Samuel · About this commentary
Sheba's Revolt and the Wise Woman of Abel
2 Samuel 20:1-26
1 There happened to be there a wicked fellow, whose name was Sheba the son of Bichri, a Benjamite; and he blew the trumpet, and said, “We have no portion in David, neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse. Every man to his tents, Israel!” · WEB
A northern secession, another murder by Joab's hand, and a town saved by one woman who asks the besieger a question.
"We have no portion in David, neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse. Every man to his tents, Israel!" 2 Samuel 20:1.
One malcontent with a trumpet turns a quarrel at a ford into a secession, and the whole north walks away. The sentence should be remembered, because it is repeated almost word for word when the kingdom finally splits under Solomon's son 1 Kings 12:16. The fracture that ends Israel's united monarchy is already fully formed here; David reunites the country by force one more time, and the seam does not heal.
The king took the ten women his concubines... and put them in custody... So they were shut up to the day of their death, living in widowhood 2 Samuel 20:3.
The verse is easy to read past and should not be. Ten women were left behind as caretakers 2 Samuel 15:16, violated in public as a political signal 2 Samuel 16:22, and now spend the rest of their lives in provided-for confinement. They chose nothing at any stage. The account states their fate plainly and blames no one, which leaves the reader to notice that the sword promised to David's house fell hardest on people who had no part in his sin.
Joab took Amasa by the beard with his right hand to kiss him... So he struck him with it in the body and shed out his bowels to the ground 2 Samuel 20:9–10.
Amasa, given three days to muster Judah, is late, and Abishai is sent instead — with Joab, demoted and unmentioned in the order, coming along. The murder is Abner's death repeated exactly 2 Samuel 3:27: a greeting, a brother's word, a concealed blade, one thrust. Joab kills his own cousin in the road to take back a command the king had given away, and the army follows him because he is the only one who can end the revolt. David never says a word about it.
"You seek to destroy a city and a mother in Israel. Why will you swallow up Yahweh's inheritance?" 2 Samuel 20:19.
At Abel of Beth Maacah the battering has begun when a woman calls over the wall and negotiates. Her argument has three parts: the town's ancient reputation for settling disputes, its peaceable loyalty, and the fact that it belongs to God. Joab, who has just murdered a kinsman, hears her out and states his actual terms — one man's head, not a city 2 Samuel 20:21.
Then the woman went to all the people in her wisdom 2 Samuel 20:22.
She persuades the town, Sheba's head comes over the wall, the trumpet sounds, and a siege ends without a breach. It is the second time in this book that a nameless wise woman changes the course of the kingdom by talking to a man who came to destroy 2 Samuel 14:2, and the pattern is deliberate: in a story full of armed men solving nothing, the two clean resolutions belong to women with arguments. The cabinet list that follows 2 Samuel 20:23–26 shows the state restored — with Joab, as ever, over the army.
settled What this mark means