Biblion Bible Commentary
Read the introduction to James · About this commentary
Has God Not Chosen the Poor?
James 2:5-7
5 Listen, my beloved brothers. Didn’t God choose those who are poor in this world to be rich in faith and heirs of the Kingdom which he promised to those who love him? · WEB
The argument against favoritism is not that it is unkind but that it contradicts God's own choosing, and then that it is stupid.
Verse 5 opens with a demand for attention — listen, my beloved brothers — and then argues from what God has done rather than from fairness. He chose the poor of this world, and the qualification is exact: poor in the world's terms, and rich in another currency, heirs of a kingdom.
The promise is attached to the same condition as the crown earlier in the letter, those who love him James 1:12. Not to poverty itself. The letter is not romanticizing the poor; it is saying where God has been looking.
Verse 6 states the consequence bluntly: you have dishonored the poor man. In seating him at the footstool the congregation has publicly reversed God's own assessment.
Then the second argument, and its tone changes completely. Do not the rich oppress you, and personally drag you into court? The letter simply points at experience. The very class being flattered is the class doing the exploiting, so the favoritism is not merely wrong but self-defeating.
Verse 7 adds the last turn. They blaspheme the honorable name by which you are called — the name invoked over these believers. So the flattery is directed at people who insult the name the congregation bears.
The passage refuses to make its case on sentiment alone. Partiality contradicts God's choice, dishonors the person God honored, and courts the people doing the harm.
settled What this mark means