Biblion Bible Commentary
Read the introduction to James · About this commentary
A Fire, a World of Iniquity
James 3:6-8
6 And the tongue is a fire. The world of iniquity among our members is the tongue, which defiles the whole body, and sets on fire the course of nature, and is set on fire by Gehenna. · WEB
The most severe description in the letter, and it ends by conceding that the problem it has described cannot be solved by effort.
Verse 6 is dense and its clauses accumulate rather than argue. The tongue is a fire, and a world of unrighteousness — a whole order of wrong, present among the members. It defiles the entire body. It sets on fire the course of life, an expression for the wheel of existence turning through its stages. And it is itself set on fire from below.
That last clause is the one that lifts the passage out of proverb. The letter has already said God tempts no one and that desire is what draws a person away James 1:13–14. Here it names a second source, and does not reconcile the two. The reader is left with a faculty that is fed from somewhere it did not choose.
Verses 7 and 8 then close the escape route. Every kind of creature has been tamed by mankind — the verb is perfect, an accomplished and continuing fact, and the list reaches across the whole creation. Humanity's record of subduing what is wild is stated at its most impressive.
And then: but no one among men can tame the tongue. The contrast is exact and it is deliberate. The one thing that cannot be domesticated is not out in the world; it is in the mouth of the person doing the domesticating.
The two descriptions that follow are unrelieved — a restless evil, full of deadly poison — and the letter offers no technique. It is not building toward a method.
settled What this mark means