Biblion Bible Commentary
Read the introduction to Joshua · About this commentary
The Gibeonites' Worn-Out Shoes
Joshua 9:1-15
1 When all the kings who were beyond the Jordan, in the hill country, and in the lowland, and on all the shore of the great sea in front of Lebanon, the Hittite, the Amorite, the Canaanite, the Perizzite, the Hivite, and the Jebusite, heard of it · WEB
The book's second failure needs no battle — a costume, moldy bread, and one omitted step: they didn't ask counsel from Yahweh's mouth.
They gathered themselves together to fight with Joshua and with Israel, with one accord Joshua 9:1–2.
The land's response to Ebal splits two ways, and the chapter is built on the contrast. The kings form a coalition; Gibeon forms a plan. Both have heard the same news — what Joshua had done to Jericho and to Ai Joshua 9:3 — and Gibeon draws Rahab's conclusion by Jacob's methods.
They also resorted to a ruse... old sacks on their donkeys, and old, torn-up and bound up wineskins, and old and patched sandals... All the bread of their food supply was dry and moldy Joshua 9:4–5.
The costume is meticulous, and its logic exploits the law itself: Israel's rules distinguished cities very far off, which could be offered peace, from the cities of the land, which could not Deuteronomy 20:10–11 Deuteronomy 20:15–16. So the lie is aimed precisely at the loophole — we have come from a far country. Now therefore make a covenant with us Joshua 9:6. Even their theology is well-rehearsed: they cite Egypt and the kings beyond the Jordan Joshua 9:9–10 and carefully omit Jericho and Ai, which travelers from a far country could not yet have heard about.
The men of Israel said to the Hivites, "What if you live among us?" Joshua 9:7.
The right question is asked — once — and then talked past. Suspicion was present; what was missing was the one act that converts suspicion into knowledge.
The men sampled their provisions, and didn't ask counsel from Yahweh's mouth Joshua 9:14.
The verse is the chapter's hinge and the book's second lesson in the same failure. They sampled the provisions — they did due diligence, handled the evidence, tasted the moldy bread — and the evidence was excellent, because it had been manufactured to be examined. Investigation is no defense against a lie designed for investigators. What was omitted was counsel from Yahweh's mouth — the priestly inquiry that stood ready Numbers 27:21 — and the omission repeats Ai's exactly Joshua 7:3: the previous failure came from acting on confident assessment after a victory, and so does this one. Israel's two defeats in this book cost no battles between them; both were lost at the planning table, where God was not consulted because the case looked clear.
Joshua made peace with them, and made a covenant with them, to let them live. The princes of the congregation swore to them Joshua 9:15.
The covenant is sworn — by Yahweh's name, as the sequel shows Joshua 9:18 — and three days later the costume comes off Joshua 9:16. What Israel does with a covenant it was tricked into swearing is the next scene's question, and the answer will echo through Scripture for centuries.
settled What this mark means