Introduction to Judges

Title and authorship

The book takes its name from the men and one woman it records, and the title needs correcting before the first page is read. A judge here is not a magistrate presiding over a courtroom. The Hebrew word covers ruling and setting things right, and what these figures mostly do is fight: Yahweh raised up judges, who saved them out of the hand of those who plundered them Judges 2:16. Twelve of them are said to have judged Israel Judges 3:10 Judges 4:4 Judges 12:7 Judges 16:31, and the office is better understood as deliverer than as arbiter — though Deborah does both, sitting to settle disputes and going out to war Judges 4:4–5.

No author is named anywhere in the book, and none of the twelve is presented as its writer. What the text does supply is a vantage point, repeated four times: in those days there was no king in Israel Judges 17:6 Judges 18:1 Judges 19:1 Judges 21:25. Someone is writing from a period when there was one, looking back on an era when there was not — which places the composition after the monarchy began and explains why the book keeps noting the absence.

Several notes point the same way. Jerusalem is described as still in Jebusite hands Judges 1:21 Judges 19:11–12, which it ceased to be under David 2 Samuel 5:6–7. Ancient tradition assigns the book to Samuel, and nothing in it contradicts that; nothing in it requires it either, and the text's silence about its author is worth respecting.

The period covered runs from the death of Joshua Judges 1:1 to the eve of the monarchy, and the book is candid that its arrangement is not simply chronological. The last five chapters are two appendices whose events belong earlier — one of them names a grandson of Moses among its priests Judges 18:30 — and they are placed at the end because of what they show rather than when they happened.

Date

The book's own dating is done by spans rather than by regnal years, and the spans are large. Four times a deliverance is followed by the same notice — the land had rest forty years Judges 3:11 Judges 5:31 Judges 8:28, and once eighty Judges 3:30 — with oppressions of eight, eighteen, twenty and forty years counted between them Judges 3:8 Judges 3:14 Judges 4:3 Judges 13:1. Added end to end the figures reach beyond four centuries, and Scripture elsewhere gives shorter totals for the same interval 1 Kings 6:1 Acts 13:20.

The difficulty resolves once the book's shape is understood. These are regional deliverances, not national reigns in sequence. Deborah's war is fought in the north, Gideon's against raiders from the east, Jephthah's across the Jordan, and Samson's on the Philistine border in the southwest — and nothing requires them to have followed one another rather than overlapped. The book itself shows two judges' periods running together, since Samson's twenty years fall inside a Philistine oppression that is still unbroken when the book ends Judges 15:20 Judges 16:31.

What frames the whole era is stated at the outset, and it is a generational fact rather than a date: after all that generation were gathered to their fathers, another generation arose after them who didn't know Yahweh, nor the work which he had done for Israel Judges 2:10. Joshua's book had closed with Israel serving God all the days of Joshua and of the elders who outlived him Joshua 24:31. One generation is the interval between that sentence and this one.

That is the book's most sobering piece of chronology. The exodus, the sea, the wilderness and the conquest were within living memory, and the memory did not transmit.

Backgrounds

Israel enters this book with the land partly taken and the job unfinished. The first chapter is a catalogue of tribal campaigns in which the recurring note is what was not driven out — the Canaanites who kept the plains because they had iron chariots, the cities that remained, the peoples reduced to forced labor instead of removed Judges 1:19 Judges 1:21 Judges 1:27–33. So the political map is a patchwork: Israelite hill country with Canaanite strongholds through the valleys and along the coast.

That geography produces the book's characteristic isolation. The tribes were separated by ridges, by unconquered fortress cities and by the Jordan, and there was no capital, no standing army and no central authority. When Deborah's song reviews who came to the war and who stayed home Judges 5:14–18, it is describing a confederation with no machinery to compel anybody. Much of the book's disorder follows directly from that: tribes acting alone, a private army of a usurper Judges 9:4, and finally a war of eleven tribes against one Judges 20:8–11.

The religion of the surrounding peoples is the other great pressure, and it was agricultural. Baal was the storm god who was thought to give rain and harvest, and the Baals and Asheroth appear throughout Judges 2:11 Judges 2:13 Judges 3:7 Judges 6:25. Settled farmers moving into unfamiliar land had every practical incentive to adopt the local rituals for local soil — which is what makes Gideon's first commission the destruction of his own father's altar Judges 6:25–27.

The oppressors change with the compass point. Mesopotamian and Moabite pressure comes early Judges 3:8 Judges 3:12, the Canaanite coalition under Sisera holds the northern plain Judges 4:2–3, Midianite camel raiders come out of the eastern desert at harvest Judges 6:3–5, Ammon presses from across the Jordan Judges 10:7, and the Philistines — newly settled on the coast with an advantage in metalwork — become the enemy the book ends still fighting Judges 13:1 Judges 16:30.

Theology and purpose

The book states its own theology in a single programmatic passage before it tells a single story properly Judges 2:11–19, and everything after that is illustration. The pattern has five stages and the text gives them plainly. Israel did that which was evil in Yahweh's sight — the formula appears seven times Judges 2:11 Judges 3:7 Judges 3:12 Judges 4:1 Judges 6:1 Judges 10:6 Judges 13:1. They are given into an oppressor's hand. They cried to Yahweh Judges 3:9 Judges 3:15 Judges 4:3 Judges 6:6 Judges 10:10. He raised up a deliverer Judges 2:16 Judges 2:18. The land had rest. And then: when the judge was dead, they turned back, and dealt more corruptly than their fathers Judges 2:19.

The last clause is what makes the book more than a cycle. More corruptly than their fathers means the pattern is not a circle but a descent, and the descent shows in the deliverers themselves. The first is Othniel, of whom nothing bad is recorded Judges 3:9–11. By the middle of the book Gideon needs three signs before he will move and ends by making an ephod that becomes a snare to his own house Judges 6:36–40 Judges 8:27. Jephthah bargains with God and pays with his daughter Judges 11:30–31. Samson, set apart from the womb Judges 13:5, spends his strength on his appetites and accomplishes more in his death than in his life Judges 16:30. The deliverers get worse as the book proceeds, and the reader is meant to notice.

Against that, the book's steady subject is God's refusal to abandon a people who keep abandoning him. The reason given for each rescue is not Israel's repentance but God's response to their pain: it grieved Yahweh because of their groaning Judges 2:18. Nothing in the cycle is earned, and the crying out is described as distress rather than reformation — when Israel does confess, God's answer is a rebuke and then a deliverance anyway Judges 10:11–16.

And the deliverance regularly comes through the least likely instrument, which is the book's second theme. Ehud is left-handed Judges 3:15, Shamgar has an ox goad Judges 3:31, Jael has a tent peg Judges 4:21, Gideon is the least in my father's house and is reduced to three hundred men so that Israel cannot claim the credit Judges 6:15 Judges 7:2, and Samson's weapon is a jawbone. Yahweh's Spirit comes on seven occasions Judges 3:10 Judges 6:34 Judges 11:29 Judges 13:25 Judges 14:6 Judges 14:19 Judges 15:14, and it comes on men whose characters would disqualify them from any office.

The purpose, then, is a diagnosis and an argument. The diagnosis is the refrain that closes the book: in those days there was no king in Israel. Everyone did that which was right in his own eyes Judges 21:25. The argument is what the book has shown for twenty-one chapters — that a people governed by its own preferences will not be governed at all, and that the God it keeps deserting keeps sending help. The New Testament reads the era generously, naming four of these flawed men among the faithful Hebrews 11:32.

Additional notes

Note — how the book handles its own violence. Judges reports assassination, mutilation, human sacrifice, mass killing, gang rape and the abduction of women, and it does so with almost no editorial comment. That silence is not approval, and reading it as approval is the commonest mistake made with this book. Two controls are supplied by the text itself. The first is the framing refrain — everyone did that which was right in his own eyes Judges 17:6 Judges 21:25 — placed around the worst material as its verdict. The second is the law the reader is assumed to know: the book's own characters break commandments the Pentateuch has already given, and the narrator expects that to be noticed rather than explained. Where Scripture narrates without comment, the narration is not an endorsement.

Note — Jephthah's vow. Whatever comes out of the doors of my house to meet me... it shall be Yahweh's, and I will offer it up for a burnt offering Judges 11:31. What the text says he vowed, what came out, and what he then did are reported Judges 11:34–39; what the text never does is commend any of it. The law he was living under condemned human sacrifice in the strongest terms it possessed and called it an abomination Leviticus 18:21 Deuteronomy 12:31 Jeremiah 32:35, and it also provided for the redemption of persons under a vow Leviticus 27:1–8 — so a lawful way out existed. Readers have long divided over whether the daughter was killed or was dedicated to perpetual virginity, and the passage's language can be pressed either way; both readings are set out where the passage is treated, and neither is given a certainty the text withholds. What is not in doubt is that a man who tried to secure God's help by bargaining destroyed what he most loved.

Note — the Spirit and character. Seven times Yahweh's Spirit comes on a man in this book, and on the last four occasions it is Samson Judges 13:25 Judges 14:6 Judges 14:19 Judges 15:14 — a man breaking his Nazirite separation, marrying against the covenant, and pursuing women in Philistine towns. The book therefore refuses a comfortable equation: the Spirit's empowering for a task is not a certificate of the man's holiness, and gifting is not the same as godliness. The same distinction is drawn in the New Testament, where the most spectacular endowment without love is nothing 1 Corinthians 13:1–2 and where those who prophesied in Christ's name may still be unknown to him Matthew 7:22–23.

Note — the two appendices, and why they are at the end. Chapters 17-21 leave the cycle behind: there is no oppressor, no crying out and no deliverer. Instead there are two episodes about Israel's own condition — a household shrine with a hired Levite, ending in a tribe adopting stolen idols Judges 17:1–13 Judges 18:30–31, and an atrocity at Gibeah that ends in near-annihilation of a tribe and the seizing of wives to repair it Judges 19:1–30 Judges 21:1–25. Both are dated early by internal evidence, and both are placed last because they answer the question the cycles raise: what was actually wrong? Not the absence of military deliverers, but corruption at the center — false worship in chapter 17 and moral collapse in chapter 19, with the refrain about no king stamped on each Judges 17:6 Judges 19:1. The book ends without a rescue, which is the point at which its reader is meant to want one.

Outline

How the book is built

The cycle, stated and then repeated parallel 2:11-16:31

• A 2:11-23 The pattern stated: Israel did evil and served the Baals, was given to plunderers, groaned, and Yahweh raised up judges — and when the judge died they dealt more corruptly than their fathers.
• B 3:7-11 Othniel — the first cycle, and the cleanest: evil, Mesopotamian oppression, a cry, the Spirit, and forty years of rest.
• C 3:12-31 Ehud and Shamgar — a left-handed man with a hidden dagger and a farmer with an ox goad; eighty years of rest, the longest in the book.
• A′ 4:1-5:31 Deborah and Barak — the cycle recurs in the north, the victory is won by a woman with a tent peg, and the song celebrates who came and names who stayed home.
• B′ 6:1-9:57 Gideon — the least in his father's house, needing signs, winning with three hundred, and ending in an ephod that snared his house; then Abimelech, his son, who was no judge but a usurper.
• C′ 10:1-16:31 Jephthah and Samson — a bargainer who paid with his daughter and a Nazirite from the womb who spent his strength on his appetites; the Philistine oppression is unbroken when the book ends.

The book sets out the pattern programmatically before narrating it, and the narrative then runs the same five stages six times. The members below pair the statement with its illustrations in the same order: evil done, an oppressor given power, a cry, a deliverer raised, rest — and then relapse, worse than before. Listing the cycles side by side is what exposes the descent, since the deliverers themselves deteriorate from Othniel, of whom nothing bad is recorded, to Samson, who accomplished more in his death than in his life.

---

Read Judges · About this commentary